site stats

Paper reviewer comments example

WebThe response to reviewers is usually organized by presenting reviewers’ comments one by one, followed by the authors’ response. Authors should distinguish their responses from … WebMar 16, 2024 · Identify the article. Start your review by referring to the title and author of the article, the title of the journal, and the year of publication in the first paragraph. For …

Paper Reviews: Sample Paper Reviews - Walden University

WebJan 18, 2024 · In this section, you should make a brief summary of what the paper is about and what the main findings are. Begin with any positive feedback you have – if you start off on a positive note, authors will be more likely to read your review. However, if you are recommending that the paper be rejected, just be careful not to overwhelm the author ... Keeping in mind the guidelines above, how do you put your thoughts into words? Here are some sample “before” and “after” reviewer comments ✗ Before “The authors appear to have no idea what they are talking about. I don’t think they have read any of the literature on this topic.” ✓ After “The study fails to address … See more Use an outline for your reviewer report so it’s easy for the editors and author to follow. This will also help you keep your comments organized. Think about structuring your review like an inverted pyramid. Put the most … See more Giving feedback is hard. Giving effective feedback can be even more challenging. Remember that your ultimate goal is to discuss what the authors would need to do in order to qualify for publication. The point is not to nitpick … See more You might find yourself in a situation where you’re not sure how to explain the problem or provide feedback in a constructive and … See more Be sure you turn in your report on time. Need an extension? Tell the journal so that they know what to expect. If you need a lot of extra time, the … See more shell tonique williams https://handsontherapist.com

Reject decisions: Sample peer review comments and examples

WebComments from Reviewer 2 Comment 1: [Paste the full comment here and italicize it.] Response: [Follow the patterns recommended above.] Comment 2: Response: Additional clarifications [Here, mention any other clarifications you would like to provide to the journal editor/reviewer.] WebApr 7, 2024 · April 7, 2024. WASHINGTON — A new batch of classified documents that appear to detail American national security secrets from Ukraine to the Middle East to China surfaced on social media sites ... WebSample peer review comments to reject a manuscript “I do not believe that this journal is a good fit for this paper.” “While the paper addresses an interesting issue, it is not publishable in its current form.” “In its current state, I do not recommend accepting this paper.” “Unfortunately, the literature review is inadequate. It lacks..” shell tonna s2 m 32 msds

General Comments from the Reviewers General …

Category:Reject decisions: Sample peer review comments and examples

Tags:Paper reviewer comments example

Paper reviewer comments example

(PDF) Writing a Response to Reviewers

WebPaper Reviews: Sample Paper Reviews Print Page Report a broken link Explanations of errors Links to resources Questions or reactions from a reader’s perspective Recommended next steps Revision strategies Highlighted patterns Models of effective writing Video clips to watch Sample Review of a Discussion Post (PDF) WebApr 3, 2024 · Your responses should be polite and objective, balancing the line between being concise and complete. There is no space for ego in your response. Start by thanking …

Paper reviewer comments example

Did you know?

WebReviewer 4 comments: Comment: This is an excellent report dealing with significant technical matters. I find no fault whatsoever with the methods, data analysis, or … WebIt is important new reviewers respect previous review comments and the efforts the author has made to revise the paper Ideally, any significant changes should already have been requested in the original review – this subsequent review should be to ensure that the changes have been made, rather than for raising additional issues.

WebFor example, a paper that holds significance only for a particular subfield of chemical engineering is not appropriate for a broad multidisciplinary journal. Determining match is usually done in partnership with the editor, who can answer questions of journal scope. Analyze your audience WebUsing Generic Performance Review Comments: An Example. So, as an example, when you’re talking about attendance, a generic performance review comment might be: “Jane has used more than her allotted sick days in this review period”. While this is a simple yes/no question, it doesn’t say much about the reason for Jane’s absence.

WebDec 17, 2024 · Peer review, sometimes referred to as refereeing, is the process of evaluating submissions to an academic journal. Using strict criteria, a panel of reviewers in the same … WebPaper Reviews: Sample Paper Reviews Print Page Report a broken link Explanations of errors Links to resources Questions or reactions from a reader’s perspective …

WebSep 30, 2024 · Reviewer comments are the most fundamental component of the peer-review process for publishing scientific manuscripts. They are also the most anxiety-laden, occasionally joyful, hopefully constructive, but often disheartening, painful, and sometimes cruel and soul-crushing element.

WebExamples of ‘major revisions’ reviewer comments “The manuscript shows a lot of promise, but some major issues need to be addressed before it can be published.” “This … shell tonna s2 mx 68 data sheetWebimprove the work and address their concerns as per the specific comments below. As noted by the Reviewer, the authors feel that the length restraint of a Brief Communication … shell toms riverWebbackground/literature review. 17. The distinction between racial category and racial markers (16/last/last) needs to be better defined/described and moved to the very beginning of the paper. 18. What “other applications are possible” (17/3/2-3)? 19. The limitations section of the paper is, well, too limited (see my comments throughout). shell tonnaWebExamples of possibly major flaws include: Drawing a conclusion that is contradicted by the author's own statistical or qualitative evidence The use of a discredited method Ignoring a … sporternaehrungs-coach.ch se🍌cWebMar 6, 2024 · One Step At a Time. When you are ready to start, a helpful approach is to resolve one comment at a time. Read it and understand what it is actually asking, and then make notes of how you will respond and what you will be required to do to make the changes in the manuscript. This process should be repeated for all of the comments … sporteria solothurnWebFor example, instead of, “The explanation of the proposed mechanism is not clear. ” You might write, “The explanation of the proposed mechanism should be more detailed. … shell tonna s2 mx 68 tdsWebexample of cover letter that can go with y our resp onse to reviewers’ comments is pro vided. The specimen/template is made up of a set of parts, each of which is presented and described in a ... sporterized arisaka type 99