WebThe response to reviewers is usually organized by presenting reviewers’ comments one by one, followed by the authors’ response. Authors should distinguish their responses from … WebMar 16, 2024 · Identify the article. Start your review by referring to the title and author of the article, the title of the journal, and the year of publication in the first paragraph. For …
Paper Reviews: Sample Paper Reviews - Walden University
WebJan 18, 2024 · In this section, you should make a brief summary of what the paper is about and what the main findings are. Begin with any positive feedback you have – if you start off on a positive note, authors will be more likely to read your review. However, if you are recommending that the paper be rejected, just be careful not to overwhelm the author ... Keeping in mind the guidelines above, how do you put your thoughts into words? Here are some sample “before” and “after” reviewer comments ✗ Before “The authors appear to have no idea what they are talking about. I don’t think they have read any of the literature on this topic.” ✓ After “The study fails to address … See more Use an outline for your reviewer report so it’s easy for the editors and author to follow. This will also help you keep your comments organized. Think about structuring your review like an inverted pyramid. Put the most … See more Giving feedback is hard. Giving effective feedback can be even more challenging. Remember that your ultimate goal is to discuss what the authors would need to do in order to qualify for publication. The point is not to nitpick … See more You might find yourself in a situation where you’re not sure how to explain the problem or provide feedback in a constructive and … See more Be sure you turn in your report on time. Need an extension? Tell the journal so that they know what to expect. If you need a lot of extra time, the … See more shell tonique williams
Reject decisions: Sample peer review comments and examples
WebComments from Reviewer 2 Comment 1: [Paste the full comment here and italicize it.] Response: [Follow the patterns recommended above.] Comment 2: Response: Additional clarifications [Here, mention any other clarifications you would like to provide to the journal editor/reviewer.] WebApr 7, 2024 · April 7, 2024. WASHINGTON — A new batch of classified documents that appear to detail American national security secrets from Ukraine to the Middle East to China surfaced on social media sites ... WebSample peer review comments to reject a manuscript “I do not believe that this journal is a good fit for this paper.” “While the paper addresses an interesting issue, it is not publishable in its current form.” “In its current state, I do not recommend accepting this paper.” “Unfortunately, the literature review is inadequate. It lacks..” shell tonna s2 m 32 msds